Physicists have created “everlasting bubbles”

Blowing soap bubbles never fails to delight one’s inner child, perhaps because they are intrinsically ephemeral, bursting after just a few minutes. Now, French physicists have succeeded in creating “everlasting bubbles” out of plastic particles, glycerol, and water, according to a new paper published in the journal Physical Review Fluids. The longest bubble they built survived for a whopping 465 days.

Bubbles have long fascinated physicists. For instance, French physicists in 2016 worked out a theoretical model for the exact mechanism for how soap bubbles form when jets of air hit a soapy film. The researchers found that bubbles only formed above a certain speed, which in turn depends on the width of the jet of air.

In 2018, we reported on how mathematicians at New York University’s Applied Math Lab had fine-tuned the method for blowing the perfect bubble based on a series of experiments with thin, soapy films. The mathematicians concluded that it’s best to use a circular wand with a 1.5-inch (3.8 cm) perimeter and gently blow at a consistent 2.7 inches per second (6.9 cm/s). Blow at higher speeds and the bubble will burst. If you use a smaller or larger wand, the same thing will happen.

And in 2020, physicists determined that a key ingredient for creating gigantic bubbles is mixing in polymers of varying strand lengths. That produces a soap film able to stretch sufficiently thin to make a giant bubble without breaking. The polymer strands become entangled, like a hairball, forming longer strands that don’t want to break apart. In the right combination, a polymer allows a soap film to reach a ‘sweet spot’ that’s viscous but also stretchy—just not so stretchy that it rips apart. Varying the length of the polymer strands resulted in a sturdier soap film.

Scientists are also interested in extending the longevity of bubbles. Bubbles naturally take on the form of a sphere: a volume of air encased in a very thin liquid skin that isolates each bubble in a foam from its neighbors. Bubbles owe their geometry to the phenomenon of surface tension, a force that arises from molecular attraction. The greater the surface area, the more energy that is required to maintain a given shape, which is why the bubbles seek to assume the shape with the least surface area: a sphere.

However, most bubbles burst within minutes in a standard atmosphere. Over time, the pull of gravity gradually drains the liquid downward, and at the same time, the liquid component slowly evaporates. As the amount of liquid decreases, the “walls” of the bubbles become very thin, and small bubbles in a foam combine into larger ones. The combination of these two effects is called “coarsening.” Adding some kind of surfactant keeps surface tension from collapsing bubbles by strengthening the thin liquid film walls that separate them. But eventually the inevitable always occurs.

In 2017, French physicists found that a spherical shell made of plastic microspheres can store pressurized gas in a tiny volume. The physicists dubbed the objects “gas marbles.” The objects are related to so-called liquid marbles—droplets of liquid coated with microscopic, liquid-repelling beads, which can roll around on a solid surface without breaking apart. While the mechanical properties of gas marbles have been the subject of several studies, no one had conducted experiments to explore the marbles’ longevity.

So Aymeric Roux of the University of Lille and several colleagues decided to fill that gap. They experimented with three different kinds of bubbles: standard soap bubbles, gas marbles made using water, and gas marbles made with water and glycerol. To make their gas marbles, Roux et al. spread plastic particles on the surface of a water bath, which jammed together to form a granular raft. Then the researchers injected a bit of air with a syringe just below the raft to form bubbles and used a spoon to push the bubbles over the raft until the entire surface of each bubble was coated with plastic particles.

The standard soap bubbles burst within a minute or so, as expected. But Roux et al. found that the plastic particle coating significantly neutralized the drainage process for the water-based gas marbles, which collapsed between six and 60 minutes. To extend the lifetime even further, the researchers needed to also neutralize the evaporation.

So they added glycerol to the water. According to the authors, glycerol has a high concentration of hydroxyl groups, which in turn have a strong affinity with water molecules, creating strong hydrogen bonds. So glycerol is better able to absorb water from air, thereby compensating for evaporation. The water/glycerol gas marbles lasted significantly longer: from five weeks to 465 days, enabling the researchers to determine the best ratio of water-to-glycerol—the perfect recipe for long-lived gas marbles.

The researchers’ work even extends beyond bubbles. They were also able to create robust composite liquid films and shape them into different objects by dipping a metallic frame below a liquid surface covered with a layer of jammed plastic particles. The frame captured particle-coated films as it was slowly lifted back up to the surface. Most notably, Roux et al. were able to build a 3D pyramid shape out of a water/glycerol liquid film. The pyramid has lasted for over 378 days (and counting).

DOI: Physical Review Fluids, 2022. 10.1103/PhysRevFluids.7.L011601  (About DOIs).

Listing image by A. Roux et al, 2022